The parable of western decadence

A professional-Ukraine demonstration in Barcelona earlier this 12 months © SOPA Photographs/LightRocket / Getty Photographs

Idealising his nation as solely an immigrant might, Frank Capra was the pure choose. The transient: a sequence of propaganda movies to shore up US public backing for the second world conflict. The “producer”: future saviour of immiserated western Europe, Normal George Marshall. The title? Why We Struggle.

Consider the implicit insecurity right here. The concept western societies lack martial fibre is so beguiling that it gnaws at leaders of the west itself. And that is after Pearl Harbor had individuals queueing as much as volunteer.

I’m certain a contrarian finance bro will insist, in case you have a look at the fitting geospatial knowledge, from a sure angle, adjusting for media bias, that the invasion of Ukraine goes nicely. For now, although, it appears the Kremlin has put an excessive amount of retailer in western decadence. Neither the resistance on the bottom nor the endurance of its sponsors within the democratic world had been bargained for. By the use of comfort, Russia has plentiful historic firm. Terrorist clerics, godless Marxists and different enemies of the west, or “Occidentalists”, share few beliefs. One is that free societies have an innate flakiness: a type of will to impotence. Whilst these enemies have did not survive, the trope does.

I don’t fake that the common westerner has learn their Hume and Spinoza. I don’t even fake they deal in such abstractions as “the west”. However there’s a lifestyle — to do with private autonomy — for which individuals have constantly endured hardship, as much as and together with a blood value. Believing in any other case isn’t just dangerous evaluation. It results in extra battle than would possibly in any other case exist.

Kremlinologists report that Vladimir Putin noticed the US exit from Afghanistan final 12 months as proof of western dilettantism. From there, it was a brief step to testing the need of the west in Ukraine. You’ll suppose that US forces had rolled as much as Kabul in 2001, poked round for a day, deplored the dearth of a Mattress Tub & Past, and flounced off. They had been there for 20 years. Regardless of the mission was — technically inept, culturally uncomprehending — it wasn’t decadent.

How a lot carnage has this misperception of the west triggered? The Empire of Japan couldn’t imagine the hermit republic that America then was would ship armed multitudes 5,000 miles away in response to someday of infamy. (And, bear in mind, by no means go away.) The Kaiser in 1914 and Saddam Hussein in 1990 made related assessments of the liberal mood. It’s not out of vainness or machismo that the west ought to insist on recognition of its combating spunk, then. It’s to avert the combating.

Final week, at a bar counter, I cycled via three small pours of white wine to search out the fitting pairing for a mackerel and dill starter. I left in some pique at having did not nail it. Don’t blame Occidentalists for questioning the mettle of a society of such risible consolation. We who stay right here don’t perceive it both, which is why the decadence thesis haunts us with its intuitive plausibility. The tradition that produced the Jazz Age shouldn’t have been capable of take and maintain Guadalcanal. Every month, I count on to see western exhaustion with Ukraine. Every month, the assist persists. Seventy per cent of Germans inform pollsters that top fuel costs received’t sap their will.

Why? The everlasting error, I believe, is to confuse the substance of liberalism (which is compromise-minded) with individuals’s attachment to it (which is much from compromising). Liberalism is sparse in content material. It has no account of the great life, however relatively permits competing ones to go at it inside a framework of guidelines. If I say “socialist structure”, as an illustration, you image one thing concrete and rectilinear. What’s liberal structure? There are Islamic guidelines about intercourse and weight-reduction plan: a liberal will be celibate or wanton, a vegan or a daily at St Johns.

Occidentalists can’t imagine {that a} creed that makes so few reality claims would encourage devotion. However right here we nonetheless are, and right here so a lot of them aren’t. The historic file is evident: it’s attainable to be dedicated to a political system that itself abjures dedication. Data of the dire alternate options helps. In the long run, rousing although it was, Capra’s work was squandered on a home viewers. It’s the different aspect that wonders why we struggle.

Electronic mail Janan at

Discover out about our newest tales first — observe @ftweekend on Twitter



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here