Boos and encores: the divisions over Russian soprano Anna Netrebko | Austria


On the opening night time of Anna Netrebko’s first run of performances on the Vienna State Opera for the reason that Kremlin launched its battle in Ukraine, the Russian soprano was met with boos as she made her entrance on stage. Exterior, a gaggle of Ukrainians protested towards her presence.

By the second of Netrebko’s three-date run as Mimi in Puccini’s La Bohéme, the complete home cheered her first aria so loudly and enthusiastically that if there have been any boos, it was unimaginable to listen to them.

The blended reactions are symbolic of her present performing life. Thought-about by many to be the best dwelling soprano, Netrebko has for greater than a decade been in a position to promote out opera homes around the globe as quickly as her identify is introduced.

However since Russia invaded Ukraine in February, consideration has shifted away from her singing and focussed extra on her perceived closeness to Vladimir Putin. The Metropolitan Opera in New York pulled Netrebko from a run of Turandot in April, changing her with a Ukrainian soprano. Different invites dried up.

The talk over Netrebko has been a part of a broader dialogue in arts, tradition and sport over how a lot particular person Russians ought to bear duty for the actions of their authorities.

The soprano’s supporters have pointed to her condemnation of the battle in a assertion she issued in March. “I expressly condemn the battle on Ukraine and my ideas are with the victims of this battle and their households,” Netrebko wrote on the time. She mentioned she had solely met Putin on a handful of events, and added: “I’m not a member of any political social gathering nor am I allied with any chief of Russia.”

Vladimir Putin awards Anna Netrebko the individuals’s artist of Russia honour throughout celebrations marking 225th anniversary of the Mariinsky theatre in 2008. {Photograph}: Dmitry Lovetsky/AP

Others observe she fastidiously prevented direct criticism of Putin within the assertion, and she or he later expressed frustration she had been compelled to talk out in any respect.

The assertion was sufficient to draw fury inside Russia. “She has a voice, however not a conscience,” wrote Vyacheslav Volodin, the chair of the Duma, describing Netrebko’s phrases as a “betrayal”.

A live performance in Novosibirsk was cancelled, because the theatre accused her of being extra concerned about ticket gross sales overseas than “the destiny of the Motherland”. Netrebko has not visited Russia since. That is proof sufficient, say her supporters, that she has gone out on a limb to oppose the battle.

“She has already put herself and her household and mates dwelling in Russia in danger by saying she condemns the battle and by defining the restricted extent of her relationship with Vladimir Putin. To go even additional and to sentence Putin can be an excessive amount of to ask of her,” Miguel Esteban, her basic supervisor advised the Guardian.

Bogdan Roščić, the director basic of the Vienna State Opera, agreed. “Ms Netrebko condemned the battle in fairly clear phrases” in March, he mentioned, and as such she was welcome to sing on the theatre. Roščić additionally cautioned towards forcing Russian artists into condemning Russia’s authorities.

“No person can exist outdoors politics. I additionally reject the notion that particularly gifted individuals needs to be forgiven issues lesser mortals are held accountable for. However that’s not the identical factor as construing an obligation for artists to preach on morals or to have these morals accepted by pitchfork mobs on Twitter,” he mentioned in written solutions to questions.

Many agree with Roščić. In Might, Netrebko sang to a full home at La Scala in Milan, and she or he has slowly reappeared on schedules throughout Europe. However she just isn’t welcome in all places. A latest live performance in Stuttgart was cancelled after the native authorities refused to permit it to go forward. Most notably, the Metropolitan Opera has made a really public declaration that Netrebko is not going to be coming again.

Ukraine’s flag is draped outside the Metropolitan Opera House at Lincoln Center in New York before a benefit concert in March.
Ukraine’s flag is draped outdoors the Metropolitan Opera Home at Lincoln Middle in New York earlier than a profit live performance in March. {Photograph}: Ron Blum/AP

“She is inextricably related to Putin,” its basic supervisor, Peter Gelb, advised the New York Occasions in June. “She has ideologically and in motion demonstrated that over a interval of years. I don’t see any approach that we might presumably do a backflip.”

The general public assault has irritated Netrebko, who has filed a labour grievance towards the Met via the American Guild of Musical Artists. “There was a notion concern and she or he needed to deal with it. However she did so voluntarily; it’s not as a result of a sure gentleman from the Met demanded it,” mentioned Esteban.

Netrebko started her profession at St Petersburg’s Mariinsky theatre, whose director, Valery Gergiev, she has known as her “godfather in music”. The conductor has been a staunch Putin supporter for years, on a number of events taking part in concert events for the Russian army.

Netrebko has been pictured occasionally with Putin, akin to in 2008 when she was awarded an honorary title by the Russian president. She has lengthy been an Austrian citizen and resident, however her identify was on an inventory of cultural figures who endorsed Putin’s election run in 2012, and in 2014, she donated cash to the Donetsk opera home in Ukraine when the territory was managed by Russian proxy forces.

Vladimir Putin joins Anna Netrebko, Placido Domingo, Valery Gergiev and Sergey Ivanov at the opening of the Mariinsky II theatre in 2013.
Vladimir Putin joins Anna Netrebko, Placido Domingo, Valery Gergiev and Sergey Ivanov on the opening of the Mariinsky II theatre in 2013. {Photograph}: Sasha Mordovets/Getty Photos

The singers had been grateful for the help, however Netrebko posed with a separatist politician and flag when making the donation, inflicting controversy. She later mentioned she had not realised what the flag stood for.

The photographs resurfaced and induced renewed controversy after the invasion in February.

Liudmyla Monastyrska, the Ukrainian soprano who changed Netrebko in Turandot on the Met, mentioned she needed her to have the ability to sing however was disillusioned by her equivocal stance.

“I don’t assume you may simply be evasive and say you’re outdoors politics. I used to be additionally a good distance from politics and from all these political video games for a few years, however now we’ve a terrorist state, and it’s important to choose sides,” Monastyrska mentioned in July, the place she was singing with the Ukrainian Freedom Orchestra, a grouping of musicians from throughout Ukraine which had fashioned for a particular world tour.

Netrebko performs during the 27th annual Victoires de la musique classique in Metz, France, in February 2020.
Netrebko performs in the course of the twenty seventh annual Victoires de la musique classique in Metz, France, in February 2020. {Photograph}: Christoph de Barry/AFP/Getty Photos

Monastyrska mentioned she spoke with Netrebko in Naples within the days earlier than Putin’s invasion, as each sopranos had been singing the a part of Aida on the metropolis’s opera home. The discuss of battle was within the air, and Netrebko had mentioned she actually hoped there can be no battle.

“Then after to not say something publicly is unusual … I feel Anya ought to have mentioned one thing instantly, on the primary day. She’s the No 1 soprano on this planet, and it takes her a month to say something clearly, after which once more she half takes it again.”

In Vienna on Sunday, it was clear that for a lot of within the viewers, Netrebko’s voice nonetheless trumps her political opinions. When she emerged again on to the stage on the curtain name they jumped to their ft and whooped. Netrebko pressed her fingers to her coronary heart, visibly delighted, and soaked up the applause.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here